The darker side of Muhammad Ali
Forums home -> General Discussion -> The darker side of Muhammad Ali
The darker side of Muhammad Ali
By ckeof001 on Jan 25, 2014 05:39 AM
The darker side of Muhammad Ali
Now that he lost the power of speech, now that he walks shakily, now that he can be safely trotted out before an adoring public with the surety that he will not offend mainstream sensibilities now that he is no longer a threat Muhammad Ali is universally loved. He was once a reviled revolutionary, but after he lit the torch to open the 1996 Olympics with a quivering hand and frozen expression, the drama of the moment jump started a love affair some would say a deification that continues to this day. Suddenly, the one time black nationalist and conscientious objector some would say draft dodger was the subject of an Academy Award winning documentary ( We Were Kings a bestselling book (David Remnick of the World even a Wheaties box cover, nearly 20 years after his last punch.
And now comes the latest twist to the Ali saga, yet more revisionism. hagiographers have tied themselves in knots trying to elevate Ali into a heroic, defiant catalyst of the anti war movement, a beacon of black independence, writes Kram, who covered Ali during 11 years at Sports Illustrated. a legacy that evolves from the intellectually loose sixties, from those who were in school then and now write romance history. In a fascinating narrative, Kram posits instead that Ali, duped by Muslims, was a Chauncey Gardiner figure straight from the pages of Jerzy Kosinski There his every utterance, heavy breathing from the know nothings to the trendy tasters of faux revolution Seldom has a public figure of such superficial depth been more wrongly perceived by the right and the left.
Kram devastating, contrarian critique takes on a fawning intelligentsia; Norman Mailer (with whom Kram once tussled at a cocktail party), Bryant Gumbel and Howard Cosell are among those on the receiving end of Kram often lethal blows. For all the deification of Ali during a recent appearance with Kram on HBO the Record With Bob Costas, Spike Lee called Ali shining black prince; to black people, he was like God Kram original reporting reminds us that Ali had a very real victim, a black man in his own right: his archnemesis Joe Frazier, still deeply wounded today by how Ali, a former friend, turned his own people against him. Time and again, Ali called Frazier a and an dumb Uncle Tom if Kram story does nothing else, at least it will remind a baby boomer press corps smitten with Ali that the fighter rhetoric was more than mere shtick, that it caused real damage.
Kram amply documents the dark side of Ali personality. Beyond that, his is the latest, and most complete, dissenting voice to the as social force school of thought. According to Mike Marqusee Song: Muhammad Ali and the Spirit of the Sixties, black conservative commentator Stanley Crouch praises Ali athletic gifts but considers the fighter stand against the Vietnam War the action a dupe not to be taken seriously. Professor Gerald Early, editor of Muhammad Ali Reader, posits that Ali a single idea in his head [his] reasons for not wanting to join the army were never terribly convincing.
Sports columnist Stan Hochman, who, like Kram, was there in the late and early during Ali banishment from boxing for refusing military induction, concurs. think Ali had only a small sense of the issues of the day and was willing to play the race card against another black man, to force people to take sides, to root for him so he could feed off their passion, Hochman wrote after the debut of last year gripping HBO documentary, I: One Nation Divisible. wanted a loud, passionate cheering section, in the arena, in the nation, in the world. Similarly, Kram makes much of the fact that Ali couldn locate Vietnam on a map, let alone explain what the dispute was all about.
The question left hanging, then, by Kram and the other dissenters is: Does one need to know policy in order to become an agent of political change? At the time, another pop culture poet of the was nasally crooning that don need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows somehow, Ali sensed something, and he navigated swirling cultural winds to end up inspiring millions by coming to symbolize political truths even he, a simple boxer, might not have fully grasped. www.officialhockeyauthentic.com/womens-youth-tj-oshie-authentic-jersey-c-1_429_433.html
Like so many of those who opposed the Vietnam War, Ali motives were, at first, personal. As Kram shows, he didn want to die at war and he didn trust that the Army would use him only as a kind of goodwill ambassador, the way it did with Joe Louis during World War II, keeping him far from harm way.
America presence in Vietnam was still popular in February 1966, when the then heavyweight champion was reclassified 1 A, fit for combat, by the Louisville draft board. In Miami, Ali was baffled. www.officialhockeyauthentic.com/womens-youth-david-backes-authentic-jersey-c-1_429_432.html me? I don understand it, he said. The New York Times Robert Lipsyte spent the day with a disoriented Ali and chronicled how Ali finally blurted out what would live on as perhaps the most pithy of all antiwar expressions, at a time when few dared oppose the conflict: I ain got no quarrel with them Vietcong.
Lipsyte presents the statement as off the cuff, a visceral reaction from a confused young man. Kram maintains that the line was dropped into his presentation by Leon X, an early Muslim watchdog and headbanger.
But it was a gradual process. Ali was still confused and troubled in the late summer of 1966, when photographer and filmmaker Gordon Parks accompanied him through the Miami ghetto for a September issue of Life magazine. He was clearly basking in his newfound inner city populism, a feeling that would inform his burgeoning radicalism. On the street, fans flocked to him, shouting their support. people like me around when they got trouble, he told Parks. Louis and Sammy Davis and other Negro bigwigs don do that. Too busy cocktailin with the whites. I don need bodyguards. You don need protection from people who love you.
Shortly thereafter, Ali global worldview expanded when, in Great Britain to fight Henry Cooper, he befriended Michael X, Britain torchbearer for black power. Michael X was widely portrayed in the British press as a hatemonger, but that didn stop Ali from accompanying him to meetings with community activists. It was a stunning alliance, made all the more stark the next year, when Michael X was first prosecuted for inciting racial hatred and then hanged in Trinidad for murder.
Back in the States, Ali was convicted in June 1967 by an all white jury for draft evasion, which carried a five year sentence. By now, the antiwar movement was picking up steam though polls showed most Americans still supported the war and Ali spoke to his first and only antiwar demonstration in Los Angeles. designed for peace and to stop the killing I for 100 percent, he said. not a leader. I not here to advise you. But I encourage you to express yourself.
By the late many black athletes followed Ali and spoke out, including football Jim Brown, basketball Bill Russell and track and field Tommie Smith and John Carlos. But Ali continued to lead the sports world in radicalism. When Esquire gave him five pages to do with what he would, he crafted (or, as Kram would suggest, had crafted for him) a political manifesto: Black athletes should all this fame the white man gave to us because we fought for his entertainment, and we can turn it around, he wrote. of beating up each other we will use our fame for freedom. He went on to make the case for reparations, long before the term ever entered the Zeitgeist, suggesting we take $25 billion earmarked for the war and instead build homes in Georgia, Mississippi and Alabama. black man who needs it is going to be given a home, he wrote. black people, we not repaying you. We ain giving you nothing. We guilty. We owe it to you.
By the time of Ali 1970 interview in the Black Scholar, it impossible to deny that he become a full fledged revolutionary. was determined to be one nigger that the white man didn get, he said. on and join something. If it isn the Muslims, at least join the Black Panthers. Join something bad I hate to see black women and men, T.J Oshie Kids Jersey once they get prestige and greatness, where they can go into ghettos and pick up little black babies and make them feel good, to go leave and marry somebody else and put the money in that race Now the white man got the heavyweight champion Joe Frazier got a white girlfriend.
Seen in the context of Ali evolution, could it be that, to Ali, such taunting of Frazier wasn just the mean spirited nastiness we see it for today? That it was also political? There is no excuse for the way Ali belittled Frazier, a once proud black man shown by Kram looking into a mirror and wondering aloud, I look like a gorilla? after Ali regaled one and all with his on Gorilla, We in Manila shtick, playing on timeworn racial stereotypes. But Ali saw Frazier who would say is a little out of my line when David Backes Authentic Jersey asked about Vietnam as a stand in for his oppressors.
in his innocence, was representing white America, says football great turned activist Brown in the HBO documentary. that will incense a revolutionary who is trying to make change and knows doggone well there no equality.
In the final analysis, to subscribe to the revisionism of Kram, Early, Crouch, Hochman et al. is to argue from the privileged perspective of hindsight, to ignore the circumstances of the day in which Ali reigned. As Marqusee points out, from 1967 to 1970, Ali had every reason to believe that if he persisted in refusing induction, not only would he never fight again he go to jail. DuBois. And yet Ali forged ahead, even when facing five years in jail.
When Kram and Lee appeared last month on HBO the Record With Bob Costas, Lee rightfully praised Kram book for advancing the parameters of debate when it comes to Ali cultural legacy. And he revealed that at last year Super Bowl, he apologized to Frazier. gotta admit, like a lot of young African Americans, I got I not going to say bamboozled I got hornswoggled by Ali, and we bought into thinking that Joe was not a black man, Lee said. But Kram also cautioned: cannot be underestimated is the effect [Ali] had on black America.
And it wasn just black people it was a lasting effect on the body politic. I sensed this at all of 7 years old. It was 1970 and we were gathered around the TV me, my 17 year old brother (who would, within two years, grow out his hair and join the counterculture) and our dad, a patriotic Cold War Democrat. As the show began, our father grumbled, VFW style, about Dick Cavett guest, this draft dodger. Who was he not to serve? Who was he to question America?
A half hour later, though, something had changed. The guest forcefully and poetically repeated the practiced arguments he been making on college campuses across the nation. I don recall specifically what he said, but it was no doubt the full litany, statements like, ain got no quarrel with them Vietcong and will die before I sell out my people for the white man money. Suddenly, the Vietnam War was being posited for what it was: the sending off of poor black boys to kill and be killed by other dark skinned boys, all at the behest of a privileged white elite. Slowly, softly, as though to himself, my father started muttering, right, he right, over and over again, a lilt of surprise in his voice. There sat my brother and I, wide eyed. We were in our living room and we were witnessing none other than Muhammad Ali altering our dad view of the world.
The actress, who'd been a lightning rod for both praise and controversy on the back of her comedy series "Girls" in 2012, rung in 2013 with a pair of Golden Globes for best actress in a comedy and best comedy series. She's nominated in both categories again, but Season 2 was a far less universally accessible thing; it went, in its 2013 season, from a show addressing the general malaise of Greenpoint post grads to an exploration of a very particular protagonist. She also wrote for the New Yorker a lot. Russell's comedy "Silver Linings Playbook." In 2013, she played to her strengths: After winning an Oscar, she starred in the second "Hunger Games" movie, on whose publicity tour she managed to charm everyone in America, and had another role in a David O. Russell comedy, "American Hustle," for which she might just win ANOTHER Oscar. By 2014, she may end up running a major studio, or serving as president.